Casebook: Appeal Cases - Housing: New build - Housing layout rethink ruled out by sprawl fears

An outline application for residential development on around 6ha of land in West Glamorgan has been rejected on the grounds that it would harm the landscape and settlement pattern of the area.

More than half of the appeal site and two adjoining fields already had permission for residential development. The appeal proposal was accompanied by a section 106 unilateral undertaking stipulating that if permission for the scheme were granted and implemented, the balance of the land currently benefiting from permission would not be developed.

The inspector noted that the portion of the site for which permission had not previously been granted was not allocated for housing and represented a very significant extension of development into the countryside unrelated to any built-up area. He found that it was a considerable distance from a main road and was separated from existing and new housing development by a wide belt of woodland and sharp changes in level. It would have an unidentified boundary and would be surrounded by open countryside, he observed.

He was unconvinced that the appeal proposal provided any clear advantages over the permitted scheme. In his view, it would result in a fragmented and poorly integrated pattern of development that would significantly encroach into a rural area, breaching planning policies that sought to minimise urban sprawl and protect the character and appearance of the countryside.

DCS No: 100039174; Inspector: David Sheers; Inquiry.


Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Sign up now
Already registered?
Sign in

Join the conversation with PlanningResource on social media

Follow Us:
Planning Jobs