Invalid unilateral undertaking tips balance towards refusal despite housing shortfall

An inspector has dismissed a proposal for 14 dwellings on the edge of a village in Warwickshire in the tilted balance of paragraph 11 of the NPPF, as the harm to the appearance and character of the area just outweighed the benefits of the housing. The latter had been diminished by an invalid unilateral undertaking regarding contributions to affordable housing and healthcare.

Sign in to continue

Sign in

Trouble signing in?

Reset password: Click here


Call: 020 8267 8121


  • 14 days access to subscriber-only content



Prices from £350 /pa*

  • Full access to for 12 months with quarterly print issues
  • Track the latest CIL developments with our live table
  • Easily keep up-to-date with the essential planning news, analysis, and policy amendments by having it delivered directly to you with the Planning Daily bulletin

Choose a Package

*For bespoke corporate packages please email or call us on 01452 835820.