Nursery site homes ruled out of line with strategy

Conflict with the council's spatial strategy in the context of an adequate housing land supply has led to dismissal of plans for 77 homes, retail and employment uses on the edge of a West Sussex village.

200-008-012 (Image Credit: Chichester DC)
200-008-012 (Image Credit: Chichester DC)

The inspector agreed that part of the site, which comprised active and dormant horticultural nurseries, could be considered previously developed but found that the majority was agricultural in nature. He noted that the local plan showed an indicative capacity in the village for 50 dwellings, which had already been exceeded. However, he also found that the plan did not set an upper ceiling on development and the scheme would have a limited impact on the area’s character and appearance.

Turning to housing land supply, the inspector examined whether there was a realistic prospect of disputed sites in the area delivering homes within five years. The NPPF, he observed, does not require absolute certainty to be shown as to the deliverability of sites. While the local plan set housing targets below objectively assessed housing need due to infrastructure constraints and an emerging local plan was likely to increase the housing requirement, he was satisfied that the council could show a five-year supply.

He acknowledged the scheme’s benefits in boosting supply of market and affordable housing and delivering employment and retail space. However, he was concerned that it would harm the local horticultural industry and be out of kilter with the spatial strategy’s aim to focus the majority of new development in higher-order settlements. The fact that the majority of the land was not previously developed also counted against granting permission, he concluded.

Inspector: John Felgate; Inquiry


Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Sign up now
Already registered?
Sign in

Join the conversation with PlanningResource on social media

Follow Us:
Planning Jobs