Clark blocks Cumbria wind turbines

Communities secretary Greg Clark has rejected a bid to build three wind turbines on a landfill site in the North West, saying it did not meet community backing requirements set out this summer.

Wind power: fresh development blocked
Wind power: fresh development blocked

Clark turned down an appeal by developer FCC Environment against Cumbria County Council’s February 2014 decision to refuse planning permission for the scheme near Workington.

The minister ruled that planning impacts identified by communities local to the site had not been addressed, and thus the proposal fell foul of arrangements set out in a written ministerial statement (WMS) in June.

A decision letter sent on behalf of Clark said: "Having applied the transitional provision set out in the June 2015 WMS, the secretary of state is not satisfied that the planning impacts identified by affected local communities have been addressed.

"These include concerns about the cumulative impacts on the character of the landscape as well as the impacts on residential amenity."

FCC Environment originally applied to the council for permission to install four 2.3MW turbines with blade tip heights of up to 99 metres, as well as associated infrastructure. The firm then removed one of the turbines when amending its scheme at appeal stage.

Planning inspector Jessica Graham found that the development would cause "substantial cumulative harm" to the character of the landscape. She added that it would result in adverse visual impacts on nearby residents and users of roads and public rights of way.

Graham said these impacts would "clearly and convincingly" outweigh the benefits of the renewable energy scheme. Clark acted in line with her advice when dismissing the appeal.

The June WMS has been cited by the minister in a number of wind power planning rejections recently, including schemes in Yorkshire and Cumbria last month.


Have you registered with us yet?

Register now to enjoy more articles and free email bulletins

Sign up now
Already registered?
Sign in

Join the conversation with PlanningResource on social media

Follow Us:
Planning Jobs