Category:
customize
new topic join search today help faq
home
login
Author
Message Text For:
** DC Forum Planning magazine 4 May 2007 - Metal fence on concrete feet **
[ FORUMS : THREADS : REFRESH : NEXT THREAD ]
Posts: 28
From: london
Registered: Jun 2004
webmaster
Forum Member


Friday, May 04, 2007 4:50 PM

View users profile Print this thread View thread in raw text format

A 2m high mesh metal fence sits on concrete feet next to a footway and protects a car sales area. The fence looks unsightly, but as it is not fixed to the ground does it require planning permission? LA.

The starting point is to consider whether the fence constitutes a building operation or is merely a "chattel" that is placed on the land, applying the tests established in Cardiff Rating Authority v Guest Keen Baldwin's Iron and Steel Co [1949]. These tests relate to the structure's size, permanence and physical attachment to the ground.

If the fence is deemed to constitute development, the need for express permission should be assessed against the provisions of class A, part 2, schedule 2 of the General Permitted Development Order 1995. This excludes fences that are more than 1m high where they are adjacent to a highway carrying vehicular traffic.

If the fence is considered not to be development, it could be argued that the use of the land on which it rests is ancillary to the primary use of the site for the display and sale of cars. Since a fence of the type you describe is usually readily demountable, it may well not need permission. PM.




Reply
Quote
Report Abuse
Top
Bottom
Next
Previous
Posts: 74

Registered: Feb 2004
Mr Grumpy
Forum Member


Friday, June 06, 2008 12:08 AM

Print this thread View thread in raw text format

I am dealing with a case just as you describe, only in my case the concrete base sections and some of the weldmesh has been concreted over - hey presto! operational development!!.
Otherwise, would there be a case of material change of use to the storage of demountable fencing?




Reply
Quote
Report Abuse
Top
Bottom
Next
Previous
Posts: 92

Registered: Aug 2007
Tufted Jake
Forum Member


Tuesday, June 10, 2008 1:55 PM

Print this thread View thread in raw text format

Seems unlikely to me that such a case could be made if the fence were actually being used as a means of enclosure.

I AM TUFTED JAKE




Reply
Quote
Report Abuse
Top
Bottom
Next
Previous
[ FORUMS : THREADS : REFRESH : NEXT THREAD ]

To take part in the forum you need to register. You will automatically be asked to register when you reply to a forum message. Alternatively, you can register by clicking here.
FuseTalk 2.2 - Copyright © 1999-2001 e-Zone Media Inc. All rights reserved.
Back to Planning Resource